When Christopher Gregory (guest star Michael Weston) -- Laila's father -- surprises Gary (James Roday Rodriguez) by hiding in his car, Gary flashes back to what happened at Peter Benoit's (guest star Andrew Leeds) house the night they broke in. Gary makes it clear to Christopher that they can't ever be seen together again. From 'not the plan,' season 4, episode 2 of 'A Million Little Things.' Watch 'A Million Little Things' WEDNESDAYS 10/9c on ABC. Stream on Hulu.