The uncoupled ladies are on pins and needles during the Week 4 rose ceremony as only Daniel’s rose is up for grabs. Sarah makes a play for it by gifting Daniel a half birthday cake. Haley makes a better move by giving the Canadian a smooch on the lips, thus ensuring her the rose. Ultimately, Sarah and Ashley I. are the two bachelorettes sent home. From Bachelor in Paradise Season 3, Week 4, Night 1. Watch all-new episodes of Bachelor in Paradise MONDAYS & TUESDAYS 8|7c.