Caila gets asked out on a date by newcomer Brett Melnick and can't decide if she wants to go or not. She has feelings for Jared but wants to explore her options. Caila tells Jared she isn't going then tells Brett she is going two times over. All the back and forth is exhausting for everyone in Paradise. Caila FINALLY makes a decision and sticks with it. She is going out with Brett. Sorry, Jared. From Bachelor in Paradise Season 3, Week 4, Night 1. Watch all-new episodes of Bachelor in Paradise MONDAYS & TUESDAYS 8|7c.