Paul talks about playing John Adams, why he was a bad President, having a lazy eye in The Holdovers, being nominated for an Oscar, attending the nominees luncheon and ruining the group photo for the writer standing next to him, living in Seattle after college, auditioning for America's Most Wanted, going to In-N-Out after winning at the Golden Globes, and why New Haven pizza is the best. Watch Jimmy Kimmel Live! WEEKNIGHTS 11:35/10:35c on ABC. Stream on Hulu.