As the Nicolettis now find themselves in debt to a mob boss, they're trying to pull whatever con they can to start getting themselves out of the hole. First up, Charlie (Milo Ventimiglia) and the gang are casing a valuable necklace at an auction, which may come with a very dubious backstory. From 'The Company You Keep,' season 1, episode 2, 'A Sparkling Reputation.' Watch 'The Company You Keep' SUNDAYS 10/9c on ABC. Stream on Hulu.